Comparative Outcomes of Large-bore Venous Access Closure Using Figure-of-eight Suture, Perclose, And Manta Devices: A Multicenter Observational Study

Document Type

Abstract

Publication Date

3-1-2026

Abstract

BACKGROUND As the use of large-bore femoral venous access increases in structural heart and electrophysiological procedures, optimizing access-site closure strategies is vital. Closure techniques include suture-mediated (Perclose), plug-based (MANTA), and manual (Figure-of-Eight) methods, but long-term comparative data remain sparse. Our study objective was to compare short- and long-term clinical outcomes of large-bore venous access closure using the Figure-of-Eight suture, Perclose ProGlide, and MANTA. METHODS A retrospective multicenter cohort study of 4,725 patients undergoing large-bore venous access (≥14 Fr) for transcatheter procedures. Primary outcome was major access site complication within 30 days. Secondary endpoints included venous thromboembolism (VTE), pseudoaneurysm, infection, and long-term patency or reintervention at 1 year. RESULTS The Figure-of-Eight technique demonstrated the lowest rate of 30-day major access complications (1.8%) compared with Perclose (2.4%) and MANTA (3.1%) (p=0.029). Minor bleeding was also lower with FoE (p=0.048), and device failure was significantly less frequent (0.3%) than Perclose (2.1%) or MANTA (2.8%) (p< 0.001). At 1 year, rates of venous thromboembolism, infection, and reintervention were low and not significantly different among the three methods. Hematomas requiring intervention were more common with MANTA (1.3%, p=0.031). CONCLUSION Among closure techniques for large-bore venous access, the Figure-of-Eight suture technique offers the most favorable short-term safety profile, with the lowest rates of major complications, bleeding, and device failure. Perclose and MANTA are effective alternatives but associated with higher technical failure rates. Long-term outcomes were similar across all groups, suggesting FoE is a low-cost, effective option in appropriately selected patients.

Publication Title

JACC: Cardiovascular Interventions

Volume

19

Issue

5

First Page

S80

Last Page

S80

Comments

Cardiovascular Research Technologies, CRT 2026 held 2026-03-07 to 2026-03-10 in Washington, USA

Open Access

Share

COinS